Barriers of Digital Health
Introduction
The healthcare industry has witnessed a significant paradigm shift in the past few years with the advent of digital health. Digital health refers to the integration of technology with healthcare services to provide efficient, accessible, and cost-effective care. While telemedicine during the pandemic saw a significant increase by 10-fold in comparison to pre-pandemic levels (by 776% during the first 3 months), there has been a constant decline post the relaxation. Despite of numerous benefits of digital health, there are still barriers that prevent patients and healthcare providers from utilizing these tools.
The purpose of this article is to explore the potential barriers that prevent patients and providers from using digital health. By understanding these obstacles, we can identify ways to overcome them to facilitate broad-based adoption, resulting in improved healthcare delivery and better patient outcomes.
On a high level some of these barriers include:
Limited Access to Technology: One significant barrier is the lack of access to technology, such as smartphones, computers, or stable internet connections. This can prevent certain individuals, particularly those in underserved communities or rural areas, from effectively utilizing digital health platforms.
Technological Literacy and Digital Skills: Many patients, particularly older adults or those with limited technology experience may face challenges in navigating and using digital health platforms. Lack of familiarity with technology and limited digital literacy can hinder their ability to fully engage with these platforms.
Privacy and Security Concerns: Privacy and security issues can pose a barrier to both patients and providers. Concerns about the protection of personal health information and data breaches may lead to hesitancy in using digital health platforms, especially for sensitive medical information.
Unequal Digital Health Adoption: There may be disparities in the adoption of digital health platforms, with certain populations or communities having limited access to these technologies or facing barriers due to socioeconomic factors. This can exacerbate existing healthcare disparities and create unequal access to healthcare services.
Provider Resistance and Limited Integration: Some healthcare providers may be hesitant to adopt digital health platforms due to concerns about disruption to their workflow, additional workload, or challenges in integrating these platforms with existing healthcare systems. Resistance from providers can limit the availability and effectiveness of digital health services.
Interoperability and Fragmentation: The fragmentation of digital health platforms and lack of interoperability between different systems can create challenges in sharing and accessing patient data. Incompatibility and the need for multiple platforms or applications can result in inefficiencies and hinder seamless communication and coordination of care.
Reliability and Technical Issues: Technical challenges, such as system downtime, connectivity issues, or software glitches, can undermine the reliability and usability of digital health platforms. Dependence on technology for healthcare services can be disruptive when these platforms encounter technical difficulties.
Patient Engagement and Motivation: Maintaining patient engagement and motivation over time can be a challenge in digital health platforms. Patients may initially show interest but struggle to sustain long-term engagement, leading to limited adherence to treatment plans or a decline in platform usage.
Addressing these barriers and challenges requires attention to equity, user experience design, training and support for users, data privacy and security measures, interoperability standards, and collaboration between stakeholders in healthcare. By addressing these challenges, digital health platforms can become more inclusive and accessible, leading to better patient outcomes and improved healthcare delivery.
Let's take the example of a chronic disease such as diabetes to illustrate the specific barriers and challenges faced by patients and providers when utilizing digital health platforms:
Challenges Faced by Patients
Accurate Data Monitoring: Diabetic patients rely on regular monitoring of their blood glucose levels, food intake, medication, and physical activity. Ensuring accurate data entry into digital health platforms can be challenging for patients, as it requires consistent and diligent tracking. Inaccurate or incomplete data entry can lead to inaccurate insights and recommendations from the platform.
Device Compatibility: Diabetic patients often use various monitoring devices such as glucose meters, continuous glucose monitors (CGMs), and insulin pumps. Ensuring compatibility between these devices and digital health platforms can be a challenge. Patients may face difficulties syncing or integrating data from different devices into a single platform for comprehensive monitoring and analysis.
Data Interpretation: Digital health platforms for diabetic patients generate a vast amount of data, including blood glucose readings, trends, and recommendations. However, patients may face challenges in interpreting this data accurately and knowing how to take appropriate actions based on the insights provided. Clear guidance and education are crucial to ensure patients can make informed decisions regarding their diabetes management.
Behavioral Change and Patient Engagement: Diabetes management often requires significant behavioral changes, such as adopting a healthy diet, increasing physical activity, and adhering to medication schedules. Encouraging patient engagement and sustaining motivation through digital platforms can be challenging. Designing user-friendly interfaces, and providing personalized feedback and rewards can help overcome this challenge.
Remote Monitoring and Support: Digital health platforms can enable remote monitoring and support for diabetic patients. However, some patients may face challenges in adapting to remote care, particularly if they require more personalized or hands-on assistance. Ensuring effective communication channels, access to healthcare professionals, and appropriate remote support systems are critical to address these challenges.
Health Disparities and Accessibility: Chronic conditions like diabetes disproportionately affect certain populations, including underserved communities and those with limited access to healthcare resources. Ensuring equitable access to digital health platforms, including considerations for language barriers, cultural sensitivities, and affordability, is essential to avoid exacerbating health disparities.
Challenges Faced by Providers
Data Overload and Interpretation: Digital health platforms can generate a large amount of patient data, including blood glucose readings, medication adherence, and lifestyle factors. Providers may face challenges in efficiently reviewing and interpreting this data to make informed clinical decisions. They need tools and systems that help them identify patterns, prioritize critical information, and extract actionable insights from the data.
Integration with Clinical Workflow: Integrating digital health platforms into existing clinical workflows can be a significant challenge. Providers may need to navigate multiple platforms or systems, including electronic health records (EHRs) and various digital health tools. Ensuring seamless integration and minimizing disruptions to their established workflow is essential to facilitate efficient and effective patient care.
Time and Resource Constraints: Providers often have limited time during patient encounters, and adding digital health platforms to their workflow may require additional time and effort. Learning how to navigate and utilize different platforms, reviewing patient-generated data, and incorporating digital health insights into their clinical decision-making process can be time-consuming. Providers need support and training to effectively manage these tasks within their busy schedules.
Patient Engagement and Adherence: While digital health platforms can empower patients to self-manage their condition, providers may face challenges in ensuring patient engagement and adherence to the recommended digital interventions. Some patients may struggle to effectively utilize the platforms, adhere to tracking and monitoring requirements, or understand the significance of the data generated. Providers need strategies to motivate and support patients in their engagement with digital health platforms.
Training and Support: Providers require adequate training and ongoing support to effectively utilize digital health platforms. They need to be proficient in using the platforms, interpreting patient-generated data, and integrating digital health insights into their clinical practice. Providing comprehensive training, ongoing technical support, and access to resources and educational materials can help address these challenges.
Though the holistic approach can maximize the benefits of digital health platforms in chronic disease management to improve patient outcomes, the challenges faced by patients and providers in case of acute diseases may differ. Some of the challenges may be:
Limited preparation time: Acute diseases often require immediate medical attention, leaving patients with little time to familiarize themselves with digital health platforms or learn how to use them effectively.
Higher stress levels: Acute diseases can cause heightened stress and anxiety for patients, potentially affecting their ability to engage with and navigate digital health platforms during such a challenging time.
Urgent need for care: Patients with acute diseases may prioritize seeking immediate medical assistance over engaging with digital health platforms, especially if the platforms do not offer immediate access to healthcare providers or emergency services.
Temporary condition: Acute diseases are often short-term or episodic, which may reduce patient motivation to engage with digital health platforms that require ongoing monitoring and self-management.
Time-sensitive decisions: Providers in acute care settings are often required to make rapid and critical decisions. Integrating digital health platforms into their workflow while maintaining efficient care delivery can pose challenges.
Information overload: Acute care situations generate a significant amount of real-time patient data. Providers may face challenges in managing and interpreting this data effectively through digital health platforms, especially during time-critical situations.
Limited patient-provider interaction time: Acute care settings often involve short patient-provider interactions due to the urgency of the situation. Digital health platforms should be designed to provide relevant and concise information to support efficient decision-making during these brief encounters.
Care coordination: In acute care scenarios, providers must coordinate care among multiple healthcare professionals and allied healthcare facilities. Digital health platforms need to facilitate seamless communication and data sharing to support effective care coordination.
There may be some differences in the barriers and challenges faced in acute care compared to chronic care, many of the overarching challenges, such as privacy concerns, interoperability issues, and technology adoption, can still apply. The time-sensitive nature of acute diseases and the need for immediate interventions may shape the priorities and focus of both patients and providers when engaging with digital health platforms in acute care settings.
Conclusion
Digital health has enormous potential to transform healthcare delivery, improve outcomes, and reduce costs. However, there are several barriers to the adoption of digital health that must be overcome. Healthcare providers, patients, digital health platform developers and policymakers must work together to remove these obstacles and facilitate the broad-based adoption of digital health to benefit all stakeholders. By ensuring streamlined workflows, providing adequate training and support, and integrating digital health platforms into the overall care delivery model, providers can effectively leverage these platforms to enhance patient care and outcomes.
Ramandeep Kaur
A versatile professional with over 12 years of experience in bridging the gap between Healthcare and Technology.